Article

Cover

Title

Lattice composite structures – current state of research and development in Russia and the world

Author

A.A. Skleznev

Organization

Joint-Stock Company “Center for Advanced Developments”
Khotkovo Moscow Region, The Russian Federation

Abstract

The paper provides an overview of the current state of research in the field of design and creation of anisogrid lattice composite structures – shell-type load-bearing structures – in Russia and abroad. Historical information about the emergence of lattice structures is provided, as well as a brief history of their formation – the research carried out, the results achieved, and the problems solved. An analysis of the use of mesh structures abroad in the aerospace industry was conducted. The paper provides generalized information on existing and currently used methods for designing anisogrid structures, applied methods for calculating mesh structures for strength, rigidity and stability, as well as on the main technological methods and techniques for manufacturing anisogrid lattice structures with a division into domestic and foreign practice. The paper presents information on current areas of application of lattice anisogrid structures in rocket technology, aviation and astronautics, and identifies a range of problematic issues and directions for future research. The work also provides examples of innovative applications of lattice anisogrid structures currently being developed, supplied with illustrations, and indicates the main scientific centers in Russia engaged in developments in the field of creation and production of composite lattice anisogrid structures.

Keywords

lattice structure, anisogrid, composite material

References

[1] Vasiliev V. V. V. G. Shukhov’s ideas in modern aerospace engineering / V. V. Vasiliev, ed. F. L. Chernousko // Actual problems of mechanics. Modern mechanics and development of V. G. Shukhov’s ideas. Moscow: Nauka, 2011, pp. 111–127.

[2] Mackay R. Wellington in action. Squadron / R. Mackay. Signal Publications. 1986. 17 p.

[3] Vasiliev V. V., Razin A. F., Andronov A. I., Salov V. A. Composite shell shaped as a body of revolution, and panel connection joint // Patent US 6068902A, McDonnell Douglas Corp./CRISM–CAT, 29.10.1997.

[4] Vasiliev V. V., Razin A. F., Salov V. A., Bunakov V. A., Soldatov S. A., Zakharevich L. P., Voldman M. Composite transverse wing rib and apparatus for producing flat cellular-ribbed structure thereof // Patent US 5993941A, McDonnell Douglas Corp./CRISM–CAT, 30.11.1999.

[5] Christopher J. Hunt, Francescogiuseppe Morabito, Chris Grace, Yian Zhao, Benjamin K. S. Woods. A review of composite lattice structures // Composite Structures, Vol. 284, 15 March 2022, 115120.

[6] Ming Li, Hengyi Zhu, Changliang Lai, Wenyi Bao, Han Han, Renbang Lin, Weiping He, Hualin Fan. Recent progresses in lightweight carbon fibre reinforced lattice cylindrical shells // Progress in Aerospace Sciences, Vol. 135, 2022, 100860.

[7] Vasiliev V. V., Razin A. F., Azarov A. V. Composite lattice structures – design, calculation and manufacturing. M.: Innovative mechanical engineering, 2023, 488 p.

[8] Vasiliev V. V., Rasin A. F. Anisogrid composite lattice structures for spacecraft and aircraft applications, Compos. Struct. 76 (1–2) (2006) 182–189.

[9] Totaro G., Spena P., Giusto G., De Nicola F., Kiryenko S., Das S. Highly efficient CFRP anisogrid lattice structures for central tubes of medium-class satellites: design. manufacturing. and performance, Compos. Struct. 258 (2021), 113368.

[10] Totaro G., De Nicola F. Recent advance on design and manufacturing of composite anisogrid structures for space launchers, Compos. Struct. 81 (2012) 570–577.

[11] Raouf N., Davar A., Pourtakdoust Seid H. Reliability analysis of composite anisogrid lattice interstage structure // Mechanics Based Design of Structures and Machines. 2020. Vol.50, Iss. 9. pp. 3322–3330.

[12] Li He, Allam Maalla, Xiao Zhou, Hua Tang. Buckling and post-buckling of anisogrid lattice-core sandwich plates with nanocomposite skins // Thin-Walled Structures, Vol. 199, 2024, 111828.

[13] Wenyi Bao, Ming Li, Xiyue An, Han Han, Yunfeng Lou, Hualin Fan. Hierarchical-level failure analysis for CFRC lattice stiffened panel // Thin-Walled Structures, Vol. 183, 2023, 110354.

[14] Yongha Kim, Ingul Kim, Jungsun Park. An approximate formulation for the progressive failure analysis of a composite lattice cylindrical panel in aerospace applications // Aerospace Science and Technology, Vol. 106, 2020, 10621.2

[15] Ming Li, Changliang Lai, Qing Zheng, Hualin Fan. Multi-failure analyses of carbon fiber reinforced anisogrid lattice cylinders // Aerospace Science and Technology, Vol. 100, 2020, 105777.

[16] Lopatin A. V., Morozov E. V., Shatov A. V. Buckling of biaxially compressed anisogrid stiffened composite cylindrical panel with clamped edges // European Journal of Mechanics – A/Solids, Vol. 85, 2021, 104090.

[17] Yeon-Gwan Lee, Jin-Ho Choi, Min-Jung Lee, Sang-Min Kim. Compressive strength stabilizing manufacturing method of anisogrid composite structure ribs without an outer skin // Composites Part B: Engineering, Vol. 203, 2020, 108452.

[18] Mohammad Mahdi Abedi, Reza Jafari Nedoushan, Mohammad Sheikhzadeh, Woong-Ryeol Yu. The crashworthiness performance of thin-walled ultralight braided lattice composite columns: Experimental and finite element study // Composites Part B: Engineering, Vol. 202, 2020, 108413.

[19] Famida Fallah, Ehsan Taati, Mohsen Asghari. Decoupled stability equation for buckling analysis of FG and multilayered cylindrical shells based on the first-order shear deformation theory // Composites Part B: Engineering, Vol. 154, 2018, pp. 225–241.

[20] Changliang Lai, Yang Hu, Qing Zheng, Hualin Fan. All-composite flanges for anisogrid lattice-core sandwich panels to bear stretching load // Composites Communications, Vol. 19, 2020, pp. 189–193.

[21] Bart J. R. Smeets, Edward M. Fagan, Kelly Matthews, Robert Telford, Brendan R. Murray, Leonid Pavlov, Bryan Weafer, Patrick Meier, Jamie Goggins. Structural testing of a shear web attachment point on a composite lattice cylinder for aerospace applications // Composites Part B: Engineering, Vol. 212, 2021, 108691.

[22] Min-Hyeok Jeon, In-Gul Kim, Kyeongsik Woo. Progressive failure analysis of anisogrid cylindrical composite lattice structure with manufacturing defects // Composite Structures, Vol. 321, 2023, 117237.

[23] Niemann S., Wagner H. N.R., Huhne C. Anisogrid stiffened panel under axial compression: Manufacturing, numerical analysis and experimental testing // Thin-Walled Structures, Vol. 161, 2021, 107483.

[24] Qing Zheng, Dazhi Jiang, Chunfang Huang, Xinlong Shang, Su Ju. Analysis of failure loads and optimal design of composite lattice cylinder under axial compression // Composite Structures, Vol. 131, 2015, pp. 885–894.

[25] Vincent K. Maes, Leonid Pavlov, Sahak M. (Samo) Simonian. An efficient semi-automated optimisation approach for (grid-stiffened) composite structures: Application to Ariane 6 Interstage // Composite Structures, Vol. 209, 2019, pp. 1042–1049.

[26] Sonell Shroff, Ertan Acar, Christos Kassapoglou. Design, analysis, fabrication, and testing of composite grid-stiffened panels for aircraft structures // Thin-Walled Structures, Vol. 119, 2017, pp. 235–246.

[27] Lopatin A. V., Morozov E. V., Shatov A. V. Axial deformability of the composite lattice cylindrical shell under compressive loading: Application to a load-carrying spacecraft tubular body // Composite Structures, Vol. 146, 2016, pp. 201–206.

[28] Totaro G. Flexural, torsional, and axial global stiffness properties of anisogrid lattice conical shells in composite material // Composite Structures, Vol. 153, 2016, pp. 738–745.

[29] Tomohiro Yokozeki, Yosuke Shimizu, Masato Ishii, Ken Kimizuka, Shigeo Suzuki, Yoshihiro Yamasaki, Keita Terashima, Toru Kamita, Takahira Aoki. Mechanical behavior in compression of skin-added X-lattice composite panel with corrugated ribs // Composite Structures, Vol. 168, 2017, pp. 863–871.

[30] Jijun Luo, Shengguang Peng, Suxia Hou, Yaser Kiani. Vibration analysis of FGM anisogrid lattice plates with one width fold based on the continuous model using the GDQE method // Thin-Walled Structures, Vol. 195, 2024, 111386.

[31] Seyed Masih Banijamali, Ali Asghar Jafari. Vibration analysis and critical speeds of a rotating functionally graded conical shell stiffened with Anisogrid lattice structure based on FSDT // Thin-Walled Structures, Vol. 188, 2023, 110841.

[32] Danli Zhang, Yong Wang, Guangyong Pan, Artin Hozuri. Nonlinear free vibration modeling of anisogrid lattice sandwich plates based on a weak formulation analysis // Communications in Nonlinear Science and Numerical Simulation, Vol. 123, 2023, 107277.

[33] Hougai Shi, Hualin Fan, Guojian Shao. Dynamic theory of composite anisogrid lattice conical shells with nonconstant stiffness and density // Applied Mathematical Modelling, Vol. 115, 2023, pp. 661–690.

[34] Bunakov V. A., Lebedev I. K. Dynamic stability of lattice structure shells made of composite materials // Scientific Bulletin of Moscow State Technical University of Civil Aviation. 2000. No. 29. pp. 45–50.

[35] Razin A. F. Calculation and experimental development of lattice composite sections of aircraft // Issues of defense equipment. Series 15. 2000. issue 1(122). pp. 23–25.

[36] Skleznev A. A. Applied method for determining natural frequencies of oscillations of cylindrical and conical lattice composite structures of spacecraft // Mechanics of composite materials and structures. 2010. Vol. 16. No. 2. pp. 241–250.

[37] Skleznev A. A. Influence of technological holes on natural frequencies of oscillations of lattice composite structures of aircraft // Bulletin of Gomel State Technical University named after P. O. Sukhoi. 2012. No. 4 (51), pp. 3–10.

[38] Babichev A. A., Vasiliev V. V., Razin A. F., Skleznev A. A., Shanygin A. N., Fomin D. Yu., Mareskin I. V. Study of resistance of composite lattice structures to impact damage // Structures from composite materials. 2021. No. 3 (163). pp. 3–6.

[39] Zinoviev P. A. Energy structural-phenomenological models of dissipative properties of anisotropic bodies and fibrous composites // Diss. … Doctor of Engineering Sciences. Moscow: Moscow State Technical University. 1997. 373 p.

[40] Skleznev A. A., Babichev A. A., Razin A. F. Design and manufacturing technology of a lattice adapter made of polymer composite materials for the simultaneous launch of several payloads // In the collection: mechanics of composite materials and structures, complex and heterogeneous media. Collection of works of the 11th All-Russian scientific conference with international participation named after I. F. Obraztsov and Yu. G. Yanovsky // Moscow, 2021, pp. 142–147.

[41] Skleznev A. A., Babichev A. A., Borisov V. N. Polyconical composite lattice payload adapter and its manufacturing technology // Bulletin of the Volgograd State Technical University. 2021. No. 2 (249). pp. 52–55.

[42] Titov V. A., Yuranev O. A., Razin A. F., Babichev A. A., Skleznev A. A., Pshenichnikov I. V., Borodulin D. A. Design and manufacture of cryogenic metal-composite fuel tanks // Composite Material Structures – interdisciplinary scientific and technical journal. 2023. No. 2 (170), pp.12–20.

[43] Razin A. F., Nikityuk V. A., Khalimanovich V. I. Analysis of lattice structures made of composite materials used in power structures of spacecraft // Structures made of composite materials. 2011. No. 2, pp. 3–7.

[44] Totaro G., Spena P., Giusto G., De Nicola F., Kiryenko S., Das S. Highly efficient CFRP anisogrid lattice structures for central tubes of medium-class satellites: Design, manufacturing, and performance // Composite Structures, Vol. 258, 2021, 113368.

[45] Mironenko E. D., Babichev A. A., Skleznev A. A. On the issue of ensuring tension of the cables of a composite high-pressure tank of a spacecraft // Bulletin of NPO im. S. A. Lavochkin. 2019. No. 1 (43), pp. 66–70.

[46] Zhul N. S., Moshkin I. D., Shaklein P. A. et al. Space platform // Patent 2688630 of the Russian Federation; declared 10.11.2016; published 05.21.2019, Bulletin No. 15.

[47] Skleznev A. A. Application of mesh composite structures in designing new aircraft // In the collection: Prospective development of science, engineering and technology. Proceedings of the II International scientific and practical conference in 2 volumes. Editor-in-chief: Gorokhov A. A., 2012, pp. 113–116.

[48] Skleznev A. A., Chervyakov A. A., Agapov I. G. Solution of the optimization problem for the purpose of designing a lattice structure made of polymer composite materials with external cladding // Scientific Bulletin of the Moscow State Technical University of Civil Aviation. 2022. Vol. 25. No. 4, pp. 70–82.

[49] Skleznev A. A., Babichev A. A. On the issue of calculating the rigidity characteristics of lattice composite structures with metal sheathing // Bulletin of the Moscow Aviation Institute. 2022. Vol. 29. No. 2, pp. 220–227.

[50] Skleznev A. A. Software for designing a composite lattice aircraft wing // Certificate of registration of computer program RU 2015614050, 06.04.2015.

[51] Muhammad Kusni, Bambang Kismono Hadi, Leonardo Gunawan, Hendri Syamsudin. Development of Anisogrid Lattice Composite Structures for Fighter Wing Applications // International journal of Aerospace Engineering, 2024, 6667586.

[52] Belardo M.A, Gardi R. A. Conceptual Design of the Junction between C/SiC Thermal Protection System and Anisogrid Fuselage Cold Structure // Procedia Engineering. 2015. Vol. 114, pp. 46–53.

[53] Skleznev A. A., Razin A. F. Concrete structures with lattice composite reinforcement // Composites and nanostructures. 2015. Vol. 7. No. 3 (27), pp. 145–150.

[54] Razin A. F., Babichev A. A., Skleznev A. A. Arctic building material reinforced by composite lattice structure // Materials Science Forum. 2019. Vol. 945, pp. 15–19.

[55] Kuzmin A. A., Babichev A. A., Skleznev A. A., Slitkov M. N. Analysis of temperature effects on large-sized products made of polymer composite materials during their manufacture and operation // Aerospace engineering, high technology and innovation. 2019. Vol. 1, pp. 71–74.

[56] Skleznev A. A., Razin A. F. Influence of the rib shape on the bearing capacity of anisogrid lattice structures // In the collection: Mechanics of composite materials and structures, complex and heterogeneous media. Collection of works of the 6th All-Russian scientific conference with international participation named after I. F. Obraztsov and Yu. G. Yanovsky: in 2 volumes. 2016, pp. 184–189.

[57] Skleznev A. A., Babichev A. A., Razin A. F. Study of the mutual influence of a workpiece made of polymer composite material and a technological mandrel on each other during the manufacturing process during temperature treatment // South Siberian Scientific Bulletin. 2023. No. 1 (47), pp. 56–60.

[58] Yeon-Gwan Lee, Dae-Oen Lee. Manufacturing technique and verification for the mechanical fastening section of carbon fiber reinforced anisogrid composite structures // Composite Structures, Vol. 268, 2021, 113895.

For citing this article

Skleznev A.A. Lattice composite structures – current state of research and development in Russia and the world // Spacecrafts & Technologies, 2024, vol. 8, no. 4, pp. 222-232.

This Article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC 4.0).